10 & 11 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Port McNicoll, Tay · Near Hwy 12 and William St. · View map
About this home
Welcome to the kind of cottage where family traditions begin and are passed down for generations. A place where mornings start with coffee on the deck as the lake comes to life, children spend the afternoons catching frogs and turtles along the shoreline, swimming until the sun begins to set, and evenings end around the fire with songs, stories, s'mores, and laughter that the family will talk about for years to come. Inside captures everything you love about Georgian Bay living. Vaulted ceilings and a bright open concept design create a warm, inviting space where everyone naturally gathers, while the cozy loft overlooks the kitchen, dining, and living areas, ensuring no one ever misses a moment. The wood stove adds the perfect touch for cool evenings after a day spent exploring the water. Outside, life slows down exactly as it should. The spacious deck is made for family dinners under the open sky, the yard is ready for games that become annual traditions, and the fire pit is where unforgettable stories are shared. Here, you'll trade busy schedules for barefoot summers, glowing sunsets, and the simple joy of watching your children grow up surrounded by nature instead of screens. Methodist Island is located at the gateway to the world famous 30,000 Islands where you can experience some of the finest freshwater boating in the world. Spend your days discovering hidden coves, quiet bays, and endless shoreline, or cruise to waterfront restaurants in Midland, Penetanguishene, Honey Harbour, and Parry Sound. Accessible only by boat, the island offers the rare gift of true privacy while remaining just a five minute ride from Victoria Harbour for groceries, the LCBO, and everyday conveniences. This isn't simply a cottage. It's where birthdays are celebrated, fish stories grow bigger every year, kids become parents, and traditions live long after the summer ends. It's a place where life slows down, families reconnect, and memories last forever.
The home
- Type
- Detached bungalow
- Style
- Bungalow-Raised
- Square footage
- 700-1100 sq ft
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 1
- Kitchens
- 1
- Rooms
- 7
- Basement
- None
- Lot size
- 200.6 x 144.4 ft
- Faces
- East
- View
- Water, Trees/Woods
- Approximate age
- 31-50 years
Ownership & fees
- Ownership
- Freehold
- Monthly condo fee
- None
- Exterior
- Wood
Heating & cooling
- Heating fuel
- Electric
- Heating type
- Baseboard
- Air conditioning
- Window Unit(s)
- Fireplace
- Yes
Garage & parking
- Total parking
- None
Taxes & other
- Property taxes
- $3,425/yr
- Tax year
- 2025
- Occupancy
- Partial
- Possession
- Flexible
- Cross street
- Hwy 12 and William St.
- Neighbourhood
- Port McNicoll
More
- Price per sq ft
- ~$555 (at 900 sq ft)
- MLS® number
- S13611936
No matching details. Ask Will instead
The home and its surroundings
- Primary Bedroom - Main Floor
- Beach
- Clear View
- Island
- Lake/Pond
- Marina
- Waterfront
- Deck
- Privacy
- Mortgage
- Property tax
- Maintenance fee
Cash needed to close
Estimates only, using Canadian semi-annual compounding, Ontario land transfer tax. Mortgage default insurance is added when you put down less than 20%. Your lender and lawyer will confirm exact numbers.
10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Port McNicoll, Tay · Near Hwy 12 and William St.
Get directionsWhat’s nearbySchools nearby
Open this tab to load nearby schools.
Your commute
Enter where you go every day to see real drive times:
Listing history for 10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A
See what this home and others at the same address were listed for, what they sold for, and how long it took.
Sold prices are for members. It’s free, takes a few seconds, and unlocks the sale history on every listing.
Frequently asked questions about 10 & 11 Methodist Island
Answers come straight from this home’s MLS® listing.
How much is 10 & 11 Methodist Island listed for, and what would it cost each month?
10 & 11 Methodist Island is listed for $499,900. With 20% down ($99,980), the mortgage payment would be roughly $2,016 a month at 4.5% over 30 years. Add property tax and the estimate comes to about $2,302 a month, all in. That figure is an illustration, not a quote.
Is 10 & 11 Methodist Island freehold or a condo, and is there a monthly fee?
10 & 11 Methodist Island is a detached bungalow in Port McNicoll, Tay. Ownership is freehold: you own the home and the lot. There is no monthly condo fee, so the roof, windows, driveway, snow and lawn are yours to look after.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 10 & 11 Methodist Island have?
10 & 11 Methodist Island has 4 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. The listing gives the style as bungalow-raised.
Does 10 & 11 Methodist Island have a garage and parking?
The listing does not show a garage. The listing does not include a parking space.
Does 10 & 11 Methodist Island have a finished basement?
No. The listing shows no basement for this home.
What style of home is 10 & 11 Methodist Island?
10 & 11 Methodist Island is a detached bungalow. A detached bungalow has all of its main living space, including the bedrooms, on one floor, usually over a full basement.
How big is 10 & 11 Methodist Island, and what is the lot size?
The listing puts the home between 700 and 1,100 sq ft. The board reports a range rather than an exact figure, and it usually leaves out the basement. The lot is listed as 200.6 x 144.4 ft.
How is 10 & 11 Methodist Island heated and cooled?
Heating is baseboard (electric). Cooling is window unit(s).
What are the property taxes for 10 & 11 Methodist Island?
Property taxes are $3,425 a year (2025), or about $285 a month.
Where is 10 & 11 Methodist Island?
10 & 11 Methodist Island is in the Port McNicoll community of Tay. The nearest main intersection is Hwy 12 and William St.. The postal code is L0K 1R0.
Is 10 & 11 Methodist Island still for sale?
Yes. It is an active listing (MLS® S13611936). Listings here update from the board through the day and come down once a home sells.
What are similar detached homes near 10 & 11 Methodist Island asking?
Similar detached homes for sale nearby right now include 856 Ney Avenue at $499,998 (4+2 bed), 679 Simcoe Avenue W at $539,000 (5 bed) and 379 Wardell Street at $549,900 (3+1 bed). These are asking prices, not sold prices. The Sold history tab shows what homes at this address went for.
What have homes at 10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A sold for?
Recent sales, leases and expired listings for this home and others at the same address are in the Sold history tab, with the price and date of each. It is free for members.
How do I book a showing at 10 & 11 Methodist Island?
Pick a day and time with Book a Tour on this page. Tours are free, with no obligation, in person or by video. You can also call or text 647-931-3923.
Have a different question? Ask about this home and get an answer, usually within the hour.
Similar detached homes nearby
More detached homes for sale near Port McNicoll, picked by style, size and price.
Detached bungalow$499,998856 Ney Avenue, Tay4+2 bed · 3 bath · Port McNicollCourtesy of: SUTTON GROUP INCENTIVE REALTY INC.View home →
Detached bungalow$539,000679 Simcoe Avenue W, Tay5 bed · 2 bath · Port McNicollCourtesy of: Forest Hill Real Estate Inc.View home →
Detached bungalow$549,900379 Wardell Street, Tay3+1 bed · 2 bath · Port McNicollCourtesy of: RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTYView home →Courtesy of: Keller Williams Home Group Realty
Listing information comes from the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board through PropTx and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. It is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA.
*Estimated monthly cost assumes 20% down, a 4.5% rate and a 30-year amortization, plus property tax. For illustration only.